Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Peter the Great Reforms Russia

Peter the Great ruled Russia as tsar from 1682 until 1725. A huge man, Peter pushed his government in many new directions. He brutally repressed protest, executing certain army mutineers personally. He moved vigorously in war, winning new territory in the Baltic region, where he located a new westward-looking capital he modestly called St. Petersburg (actually named after St. Peter though, not the tsar himself). With its military success, Russia was on its way to becoming a major European. It was already a growing empire in Central Asia.

Peter was also eager to update Russia’s administration and economy, which he saw as essential for military purposes and to establish Russian prestige and position in the wider European arena. His measures were both symbolic and real: He enforced Western-style dress on his boyars (the nobles) and required them to cut off their Mongol-style beards. He developed a major iron industry to serve as a basis for armaments production and to avoid Russian dependence on the West in this crucial sector.

The following documents I would like you to read (you can read them all by clicking here) show a number of Peter’s initiatives to reform Russia and bring it in line with Western patterns. In these reforms, Peter sets up an administrative council to improve the direction of the state bureaucracy and expand its functions. He works to improve education, particularly of the nobility, and to facilitate manufacturing as well. These reforms, in sum, give a good picture of the directions in which the tsar was pushing his vast empire.

Peter’s reforms also suggest important links with authoritarian political trends in Russia, including a willingness to regiment ordinary workers and peasants. While other European rulers at this time, such as Louis XIV in France, were claiming new powers in the name of military goals, Peter seemed unusually free to order his nobility about and command their service. He was not interested in aspects of Western politics such as parliaments that stressed restraints on the monarch. Not surprisingly, then, Peter’s vision of a Westernized Russia proved highly selective, as he found certain aspects of the Russian tradition eminently useful. Peter’s reforms must be interpreted in terms of how much they changed, but also in terms of their confirmation of distinctive features of the Russian state and society.

Peter the Great clearly illustrates a reform process from the top down. How do you think Russians at various levels would have reacted? From what you can judge by these documents, was Peter moving Russia in a useful direction? What were the main purposes of Peter’s reforms? What relationship between tsar and nobility did the reforms suggest? What kind of economy was Peter seeking to build? For what reasons? How did Peter’s moves relate to changes occurring in Western European politics and culture around 1700? What major trends did Peter ignore? Did Peter’s reforms make Russian society more or less like that of Western Europe at the time? In what ways did Russian reactions to the West differ from those of other parts of the world in the early modern period, and why? Your thoughts…

34 comments:

Anonymous said...

haha I thought that St. Petersburg was named after Peter the Great :) good to know. good to know.

Well it was interesting to read is goals and reforms for Russia in DETAIL rather than the 2 paragraphs he has in the textbook.

I have to say I was suprised to see that education was a large section in his goals. I remember in the reading that Peter requested immediately upon return from his tour through Europe for Geometry and mathematic skilled peoples to enhance the technology for the future military. In this section that we were supposed to read...under the education section he specifically said Geometry for one of the courses....I thought that was pretty interesting :)

Spectre82 said...

The document shows me that peter, really reformed russia. I particularly liked the way that he made military now mandatory for all boyars that were ages ten to fifteen. Also the way that he made them learn navigation in: III. AN INSTRUCTION TO RUSSIAN STUDENTS ABROAD STUDYING NAVIGATION.

cameron green said...

(i feel dumb i got the reading quiz question wrong with the st petersburg answer lol my bad)

i think the beard cutting was real smart, i mean really anytime you want to really show that you are a different group of people the best way is to change your appearance.

i am not a fan of forcing people to be in the military like the draft we used to have but hey whatever works best. it worked so its all good. (i hope)

i think its cool that petere had an exact plan and knew how he was going to acomplish everything. thats the sign of a great leader




probablt inforced the name: peter the great.

wow im dumb

Lora Persyn said...

I'm impressed with these sudden changes, it was probably hard to take on so much at once.I doubt many people in Russia, especially boyars, were very happy about having to get an education to get married. I think Peter was definitely moving Russia in a useful direction. Even it if he had to totally copy Europe to do it, but it's a start. All of his reforms were centered aroung military: Recruiting young men AND educated boyars for training, studying navigation, changing the economy in order to produce more metals for weapons, and putting certain officials in charge of collecting taxes. As far as ignoring western policies, I'm surprised the Russians didn't take to exploring as soon as they could, and he seems to put much more of an emphasis on education. Then again, maybe he was just trying to catch up.

Jordyn Farrell said...

Peter the Great truly does want to be very similar to Western Europe. He also wants to get Russia back on the world trade map and get Russia back up to speed on what was happening during their occupation by the Mongols. He definitely seems to want to build up the navy and explore as he sent tons of people to school to learn navigation. He also played a hand in the role of education for at least the nobles, so he seems to be rising them up a bit higher. He seems to want to join the Western Europeans, probably in hopes of sharing some of their wealth and glory.

TmcC said...

Although much is mentioned about education, economics, navagation, blah blah blah like everyone said all of his decrees seemed to be focused on the nobility and wealthy, none of the documents contain any decrees regarding the serfs other than "To collect as much money as possible because money is the artery of war" since serfs had little wealth the need for money could mean higher taxes upon them. Eventhough Peter greatly(haha) emphasized education he did not say anywhere education for all but mainly focuses on the rich and what he feels will further the higher thinkers in Russia not the commoners. Could this possibly have implications in the Season 4 or 5 (which ever one contains the Bolshevick Revolution)

Alina said...

a lot of it seemed common sense. obviously make sure that the money wasn't being wasted. if russia wanted to catch up, peter knew that they needed a better military, as well as a boost in trade. he also knew that to get ahead education reforms would be good. that kinda reminded me of the universities in china that taught people in order for them to take civil service exams, only instead of it being common people it was nobility. to me that kinda shows that instead of treating nobility like ivan the terrible did, he is kinda giving them a bit of power but is making sure that they will do well with it.

Anonymous said...

cameron, i did 2....i feel stupid getting a bad grade on my first reading quiz..oh well..

peter was really into it cause he was totally just listing everything and keeping it strict...i guess he did it for Russia's future...he just suddenly brought out the western russia in no time!

he doesn't seem to hate the nobles that much but when he puts their kids in the military is kinda wrong... im still surprised at how he did it..

Anonymous said...

Peter the great, in my opinion, created a society that closely resembles those of today, though highly militaristic. Benefits for soldiers, a draft, a strong army, and a strong navy. He hired aristocrats to study mathematics and geometry for the development of accurate weaponry.

Kailey Carroll said...

I think that the lower level Russians would not appreciate the school system put in place as much as the nobility would because these schools are mainly directed toward the education of nobility and not for example of peasants who didn't need to attend the schools to learn how to do their jobs.
I do feel that Peter was moving Russia into a useful direction because he was educating the people more on the tactics of military in turn, making them better at war, and he was also making a distinction between the learning of the arts and other subjects such as mathematics, he also forced the nobility to go to schools making the society as a whole, a little bit smarter and more intellectual on how to better their country because more people with a say in the community were educated.

Mimi Phan said...

Peter the Great really does live up to his title. Instead of focusing on one main point of reform, military, he also made sure that education was critical. Peter's requirement of the 1000 educated boyars kind of reminded me of China's exams. The more educated you were, the more opportunities you were offered. Just like the Westerners, Peter enforced the idea of navigation, which explains why he urged them to learn geometry (you need to know triangles to be able to sail). With learned skills of navigation, Peter would be able to find and conquer new lands and open up more trade. He also made sure that the money spent was going to be invested wisely, like in weaponry and education. Peter's purpose for all of these changes was to catch up to Western Europe and build a strong empire. He didn't necessarily want to become like Western Europe, he just borrowed the ideas that he thought were needed to better Russia. Peter's reformation and ideas definitely led Russia in the right direction.

Marc Flick said...

I think what Peter did for Russia was what they needed in order to catch up with western europe. I like what he did by giving the children of the nobility a free, and mandatory education, and establishing an academy for the learning of arts and sciences.

angiem said...

well based on the documents, Peter knew what he wanted to plan on. His goals/ reforms seem well thought on.

It is easy to see how his main focus was to set up a military. I also liked his lessons and rules that were for the Russian students.

In short, Peter the Great seems to me to be a useful ruler to move Russia forward..

The Odyssey said...

the most interesting part to me was about peters goals and reforms for russia. i liked mainly how he made military mmandatory for kids ages 10 to 15. also i liked how one of his goals was for education and i was very shocked at that

Tyler said...

Peter the great moved Russia to a more westernized life style. I think Peter was doing what needed to be done for Russia to gain as much power as European countries like Peter wanted. To do this he needed to build up his millitary, educate his people better, and set up trade throughout Russia. And he did all these things even if he did it brutally. It had to be done if he wanted to further advance Russia.

Anonymous said...

The documents really showed how Peter the Great wanted to modernize Russia and make them as updated as the West. He definately Westernized. It's amazing how he immediately jumped into it; it seemed like he planned out everything and knew what to do.

Anonymous said...

Well... i thought the reforms were kinda surprising. Its great that they started to focus on education ... but for the wrong reasons. Its put towards military, and militaries lead to mass killings of people. Im thinking that the starting of people thinking in a more complex way lead to chaos and hatred. People became more selfish and argumentative because of it since we all think we are right a majority of the time. now we get to the time where knowledge is used for killing? something about that seems inhumane. We have become so dependent on complex thinking that education has become our route to survival. I definitely don't see animals like skunks killing off thousands of there own kind in order to just expand and gain power. Would we have been better off dumb?
Anyways, that was kind of off topic but it is how i think of the reform. The reform was definitely needed at the time period. It was to the point-of-no-return. But even keeping up with the times caused them to a bunch of issues. It always seems that throughout history, something is changed for the better but then it comes back around and bites us in the butt. there is definitely no solution to any problem cause another problem always arises after.

hochanlee said...

It is funny that only thing peter really wanted to do was to make russia a military power machine. Even the education was for the how to shoot cannons accuately.

alex bullock said...

i am definitley impressed with the sudden reforms Peter made. he knew what he wanted and went for it. i thought that him going to Western Europe in desguise to really "research" what he wanted. he went as a normal person and to think that lead him to creating a Navy.
By making men cut their beards off or pay a tax really showed how dedicated and what a new society Russia had become.
i didnt like the forceful military, like the draft. you should be able to choose if you want to fight or not.

Henry A. said...

The document shows the actual reform impact he had on Russia. His ways of being a "good Manager" impressed me the most by going in disquise and actually learning the skills before making people do it. And his putting boyars into forced military doesnt seem that bad either.

Theresa Dang said...

Peter The Great did make a lot of changes. he seemed very serious about his work & job but i thought it was pretty funny how men were suppose to shave their beards. It's good that he did focus on education..well mostly math & science..for war, but at least he cared about education. The first thing on the study navigation made me think of war right away. Of course he wanted a navy and all that, but why was he so focused on military power? did something happen to him in his earlier years that made him who he was then?
At first, i did think that St. Petersburg was named after him, but then it turns out that it was actually named after a saint. But why that saint?..was it his saint name or something?

Jacob Wisner said...

Peter the Great does live up to his title. The way he actually would do things himself astounds me, and is very rare to find in monarchs like that in that era (that i know about anyway). It is sad how the textbook makes him seem like a nobody, but after todays lecture, it is nice to know that wasnt the case at all.

Avni Patel said...

Peter the Great was truly an important figure in Russian history. He was the one of the first czars to realize that Russia was quite behind the rest of the world. Therefore is main goal was to bring westernization to Russia.As i read through the document i noticed that alot of his thinking had to do with the military. And his education plans were also used for Russia's army in one way or another.Also, Peter wasnt trying to biuld any sort of export economy but rather an economy wiht little trade so the goods could be used for their own.

Anonymous said...

I noticed that Peter required that members of the nobility be found to be officers. What was interesting to me is that he said to especially look for those who tried to evade becoming an officer. I thought this was a very smart move by Peter because now the people that would be the most likely to challenge his power, those who would not comply to his requests, are the ones he has given just enough power in the government or military to keep quiet.

Andi Braemer said...

so were the people of russia acctually okay with this 'westernization' or were they just being forced to go along with it?
like i get that it would make them somewhat more advanced, but like it seemed weird that they all the sudden would do the war thing and everyone was just okay with it..

Prill said...

it really didn't matter what the people wanted, this is an absolute monarchy.

lydia huh said...

its impressing seeing russia go through so many changes. what i found most interesting about the way Peter the Great changed russia is having boyars go through such hard studying so that they can make the aim accurately. i dont think anyone would have thought about that. Also, what made him a Great leader was that he new his stuff before having his people doing something. for example, how he went through a lot of studying on how to make his millitary better or how to build ships, so that HE can teach his people.

Smurphy said...

Although Western Europe was seen as the 'big guy' in this time, I think it was dumb to follow their plan. And, I might contradict myself in saying this because it did work, however, I think Peter the Great could have been a bit more original.
Copying Europe did build the first traces of the new Russia, and Peter the Great allowed for that to happen. I look at the state after his attempt to strengthen Russia, and I notice a dramatic difference, especially in the widespread trade, such as with China and Persia. He planned on building his economy based off the enterprises of silver, copper, coal, silk, etc. But everything earned (taxes included) was sent to improve the military, which was a very strategic move, because one of Peter's goals was to expand. Strong military = faster expansion.
Peter's intentions were all smart, and they did benefit the growth of Russia, so they were quite good overall for the state.
But I wish Mr. Peter was a tad more creative with his ideas. :]

Nicole Gustafson said...

Peter was very strict and in control! gz. So much so, that men couldn't get married until they passed the education he wanted them to do. He is in control of marrages and knows how to make the people do what he wants. The education was a good quality to have for the people, nobles at least. He is very big on military! Much reward comes from knowing ships and the sea, because that is what their world revolves around now. The push into arts and literature suprises me. I thought military was the most important. Maybe he was trying to catch up by having a mini enlightenment period with the stimulation of arts and sciences and mathematics, although for military purposes as well. It is how the Europeans reached the core, so a catch up game still. He was more like west. Europe in that he was trying to get people educated, good military, new look and style, etc. But in the process he drove them a different way with serfs becoming ever lower in society when that was already out of W.E. a long time ago.

madison archer said...

It surprised me how well thought out the education system was. I didn't expect it to be that organized. All of the document stalked about making Russia better which just continues to show how Russia was concentrating on building its own economy up by itself without trade.

MCDA said...

He was mainly focused on the boyars and wealth of himself and the government. but one thing that sticks out of the bunch is education. even if it is all for military purposes. A mistake peter makes is that he focuses Too much on the military power and not doing anything about the peasants serfdom. I know he doesnt want to jepordize his position as an absolute monarch but whatever. I think he should help out the poor people; Anyways as long as the boyars are happy and out of the way, the peasants arent peter's problem. Peter's selective borrowing was a smart move on his part and definitely a good start to modernize Russia.

Anonymous said...

wow. im impressed in his reformation of russia. this really opened up russia to europian everything. like you said in class how he worked in all these different jobs to gain a stratagy and plan for when he returns...he seems really smar t even if his main intent is to expand by military achievements, but in the end all of this westernization and catching up got themselves in trouble

Kevin_Shin said...

You just have to respect Peter the Great for creating so much change successfully. So much power....

He westernized Russia and all, but it seems to be all for its military. He made sure education was mandatory to the extent that nobody is to be married unless they have learned geometry and algebra. But this education was for the wrong reasons. It was used to aim cannons and arrows accurately on their enemies.



On Decree #3 it says " to collect as much money as possible because money is the artery of war"

This document states that Peter allowed factories to be built for the benefit of the state. What the really mean is that the factories benefited the military lol. These factories were used to mine resources such as iron and silver. These metals were obviously used for weapons and armors.

In conclusion, he was a great leader and all, but he focused way to much on military.

CharleyYang said...

peter basically made a war machine