Tuesday, February 10, 2009

The Sting of Racism in World History

If you have been reading the blog closely since the Season 4 Premiere, you may have noticed a new and significant theme in some writers, i.e. the attention given to perceived racial differences and hierarchies. Rudyard Kipling’s poem, "The White Man's Burden", first published in 1899 in a leading American magazine, is one of the best known illustrations of the late 19th century trend toward racialized thinking in England and the United States. On this same blog, the documents by the English soldier F. D. Lugard and the French Prime Minister Jules Ferry, both written somewhat earlier than the Kipling poem, suggest a context in which the existence of racial hierarchies was taken for granted by many Europeans and Americans. Also noteworthy in documents from around 1900 is the use of racial categories by Kang Youwei, a Chinese reformer of the 1890s, and by Yamagata Aritomo, a Japanese military leader (you’ll be reading both of these documents next week).

The documents I would like you to read now illustrate the rise of racism in the late 19th century by drawing on the memories of two influential writers and political activists who came of age in the 1890s, W. E. B. Du Bois and Mohandas K. Gandhi. Du Bois grew up in a small town in western Massachusetts, earned a Ph.D. in history from Harvard (becoming the first African American to do so), wrote numerous scholarly works of history and sociology, was one of the founders of the NAACP (National Association for the Advancement of Colored People), and had a long career as a writer and activist on behalf of racial and social equality in the United States and internationally. The document I would like you to read from Du Bois (you can read it by clicking here) centers on a memory from his childhood and is taken from his classic collection of essays, The Souls of Black Folk, in which he wrote that “the problem of the 20th century is the problem of the color-line.” Mohandas Gandhi, later called Mahatma (“Great Soul”), was born to a wealthy Hindu family in western India. After completing legal studies in London, he decided to practice law in South Africa, then a British colony with a large Indian expatriate community. The document I would like you to read by Gandhi comes from his autobiography (you can read excerpts from it by clicking here; please read pgs. 111-115), first published in the 1920s, and recalls his introduction to racial prejudice in South Africa shortly after his arrival there in 1893. How do these two documents help one to understand the growing importance of racism in the late 19th century world?

After reading the documents, I would like you all to think about and discuss the following: What did Du Bois mean by “twoness?” How did Gandhi respond to the insults and mistreatment he received in South Africa? What political, economic, and cultural developments explain the rise of racism in the 19th century world? What was the connection between American racism and European discussions of imperialism? To what extent was Du Bois correct about the importance of the “color-line” in the 20th century? What is a race? What has happened to racism in world history since the early 20th century? Your thoughts…

25 comments:

ian nicely said...

mr prill i have been quite ill for the past few days and have spent most of my time running between my bedroom and bathroom. i have done a bit of reaserch and reading for the discussion tomorrow but i am not sure if i will bbe able to finish it. i know i will be coming to school no matter how i am feeling but im not sure if i will have this completed

maddiewatson said...

Hey Prill I have a question about the debate. For our questions do we have to have a written rebut ready or can we just have thought about it and know what to say?

maddiewatson said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Prill said...

just be ready to verbally rebut...

Theresa Dang said...

Mr.Prill. i have a question about the debate. Is the description of whether we agree or disagree with the position & the why or why not PART of the one page paper? or is it gonna be one page on the topic and then on the second page, our opinion?

madison archer said...

One thing I find extremely ironic is that according to scientific racism whites are the morally superior race and yet they are the ones exploiting weak countries and causing injustice literally on a global scale.


It makes me feel a little embarassed to be white haha

xchelseaPEELEx said...

hey prill...are you there? which are the documents for the debate?

xchelseaPEELEx said...

did you delete my question?

xchelseaPEELEx said...

oh oops never mind...didn't look at the time.

Prill said...

all on one page miss dang...

miss peele, did you read the directions given and listen to the directions given in class?

Macy Stucke said...

I think it is funny that the white people said that they are superior to everyone else and that they are morally correct. Of cource they would say that becuase they were the ones doing the classification so they weren't going to say something negative about themselves even when they are doing immoral things.

Anonymous said...

It makes no sense that the white people are able to classify themselves as the superior race, even though they are the ones who are taking over these other countries, and it is not like they are asking anyone elses opinion. This is not correct at all.

Anonymous said...

I remember talking about race last year in human geography. I remember learning the difference between ethnicity and race. There was nothing at all biological about race. It was just a category that humans had created to separate themselves.

Anonymous said...

In the second line it says, "Send forth the best ye breed.", referring to the white man. Obviously Kipling sees whites at the top of society, but he is also referring to whites as the best breed. What are humans then, dogs? And in that case, we still discriminate by wanting purebred dogs. People seeing some dogs as superior to others is the same thing as seeing whites as superior to other races.

Abbi Edwards said...

I just feel extremely bad for the harsh actions and words brought on the be "superior" whites. Like how the african race feels like a PROBLEM??? Thats just sad and shows how mean and un sensitive whites were to classifing blacks an indians. They don't let Ghandi even ride in the same car as them when he clearly has a ticket! It's just sad and well yeah i kinda feel ashamed about this stuff!!

Anonymous said...

it is very sad how hey tared gandhi at the train making him get off just because som hite prson flt uncomfortable? that makes no sense its not like peopl wih a diffrnt skin color ar below ou or anythng hey dont have a disease or anyting. its wrong was rong and will alys b rong for ny on race or peon to think he is superior to anoher. and whn the man old gandhi to sit on the foot sool becus h fl like smoking what is that? he is the one ho told gandhi to si in that seat in th first place now he wants no move him. its is rong how whites thought they wre the suprior race? what make a race superior? nothing vryone is the same.

Macy Stucke said...

I have a question about the test tomorrrow. What do we all have to know about the Rudyard Kipling?

cori kempshall said...

I think its so wrong for the west to think that just because they own the western hemisphere they think its their right to go and industrialize the rest of the world. Africa didnt ask for it.

KelseyBengochea said...

extremely ironic... I really don't like the white man's mentality in this document and really don't want to be white right now.... i mean who gave the whites the right to say that they are superior... what would have happened if the asian people (all of them) claimed that they were the "superior race"??????

Theresa Dang said...

wow. the whites really thought they were very "superior". yeah,they are so superior that they make everyone else look bad. and the whole gandi thing was sad as well. they are so retarded about him just there on the train. and the insult gandi got was absurd. i felt bad for him

yongpark said...

I think that this is pretty messed up. Some people think this is absolutely normal and we still live in a society with some people not knowing all this. Who knows what else the government is hiding from us. We think so small scale. The Europeans said that they are superior to everyone else and that they are morally correct and had the right to do whatever the heck they wanted to. But of course they would say that because they were the ones putting their words into official documents.

Ben Doty said...

Gandhi is forced to deal with racism and unfair treatment while he is boarding the train. He has a first class ticket but because he is of a different color, he is ridiculed and told to move back to the van compartment. He refuses until a policeman kicks him out of the train. Through all of his struggles, he remains peaceful and starts chipping away at the whites racist views. DuBois describes himself as being a problem to the rest of society. He describes the acts of racism and how he is treated wrongly everyday.

Spectre82 said...

well, the documents are somewhat disturbing. I can see why imperialism was a reality during the ninteenth century. Racial superiority was such a problem back then and we complain about it now. Back then they thaught this ideology in most schools to get the kids on the imperialist adgenda early on in life. They got the kids thinking like that, and so it stuck with them their whole lives. Shocking indeed.

MCDA said...

none of these "inferior" races deserve to be talked about or treated the way they are here. whites are in no way superior and should not be considered surperior. i think its really stupid and ignorant. we are not breeds of different people, we are just humans of different color. now if everyong was blind, wuould we make divisions based on voice tone? No, we would not because that is absurd. well its the same thing here.

The Odyssey said...

it is hilarious that white people say that they are superior to other but in reality they are the ones that are leaving out and takin over weak countries.
that is messed up!